3 Ways Closing a Credit Card Can Hurt Your Credit

3 Ways Closing a Credit Card Can Hurt Your Credit

credit card advice

Brittney Mayer
By: Brittney Mayer
Posted: October 17, 2017
Opinions expressed here are ours alone, and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by any issuer. Site may be compensated through the issuer affiliate programs.

I still remember getting my first credit card in the mail. I can recall the feelings of wonder and excitement as I thought about everything I could now do and the huge sense of awe that such a little piece of plastic could hold so much financial power.

No matter how fantastic your initial experience, of course, the novelty of a new card starts to wear off after a while. And when fancier cards — ones sporting higher limits and better rewards — come knocking, many of us start to think about an upgrade, and about closing those old accounts once and for all.

Before you turn your unused credit cards into colorful confetti, however, it’s important to consider the possible consequences that decision will have on your credit score. Just as opening a new credit account can impact your score, so, too, can closing an old one — and rarely for the better.

1. Closing High-Limit Cards Can Increase Your Utilization Rate

Whether talking about your FICO credit score or a number from VantageScore, the same general factors are going to go into your credit score calculation. While your payment history has the biggest influence on either score (it’s 35% of your FICO score), the amount of debt you owe — and how much you could owe — will also play a big role (30%-of-your-FICO big).

When considering your revolving credit lines, scoring models will look at what’s called your utilization rate, which is the ratio of your credit card balance over your total credit line. For example, if imaginary cardholder, Leonardo, has a credit card with a balance of $500 and a total credit limit of $2,000, then Leonardo’s utilization for that card is: $500 / $2,000 = 0.25 = 25%.

In addition to the utilization rate of each card, the model will also look at your overall utilization rate. In Leonardo’s case, suppose he has two other credit cards, each with balances as described in the table below. Taking all of his credit card balances and credit lines into account, his overall utilization rate would be equal to about 0.27, or 27%.

Chart Showing Example of Utilization Rates

Although there are no hard-and-fast rules on the perfect utilization rate, in general, a lower utilization rate will always be better. While individual utilization rates are important, your overall utilization tells the bigger story about your credit risk. A common rule of thumb is that an overall utilization rate above 30% will start to have negative impacts on your credit score.

And that’s where closing a credit card account can have a big impact on your credit score — a big, negative impact. That’s because, depending on the size of the credit line associated with that card, you could potentially be decreasing your overall available credit fairly significantly by closing the account and losing the added credit.

Unless you pay down your existing balances, decreasing your available credit will increase your utilization rate. If your utilization gets too high, your credit score will respond — in the other direction. In Leonardo’s case, closing his unused credit card, Card B, would increase his overall utilization rate well past 30% and likely drop his score by a dozen points or more.

2. Eliminating Old Cards Can Lower Your Average Account Age

Another important factor in both major credit scoring models is the length of your credit history and the average age of your accounts, which jointly contribute to 15% of your FICO score. So far as scoring agencies — and future lenders — are concerned, old accounts are the best accounts (so long as they’re in good standing), as they show you can maintain credit in the long term, not just for a little while.

Chart Showing Ideal Average Account Age for FICO

In fact, consumers with the highest credit scores tend to have long credit histories and high average account ages. According to FICO, the average consumer in the 800 to 850 range has a credit history more than a quarter century and an average account age over a decade.

So, given the importance of letting your accounts age, if the credit card account you intend to close is one of your longer-lived credit accounts, then closing it could be a huge hit to your credit score.

Here’s another example with our imaginary consumer, Leonardo. Let’s say Leonardo’s credit profile contains five different accounts, including his three credit cards from the last example, and each account age is as outlined in the chart below. As the chart shows, Leonardo’s oldest account is thus his first credit card, Card A, which he’s been using for 10 years.

Chart Showing Example Account Ages

Adding together the age of all of his accounts, then dividing the sum by the number of accounts (five, in this case), gives us an average account age of 5.4 years. This means that, for Leonardo, closing an account older than 5.4 years will cause his average age to decrease, potentially decreasing his credit score, as well.

In other words, given the relatively young age of his newest credit card, Card C, closing that account would not actually have a negative impact on his average account age. Were Leonardo to close his unused Card B, however, his average account age would decrease.

Furthermore, were Leonard to pay off and close his oldest credit card, Card A, not only would his average age drop by more than a year, but the total length of his credit history would decrease by three years. In other words, closing Card A could result in a loss of dozens of credit score points.

3. Canceling Cards Can Decrease Your Credit Diversity

Finally, closing your credit card could impact one of the lesser-known credit-scoring factors: your credit mix. Worth 10% of your FICO score and also considered by VantageScore models, your credit mix — the different types of credit products you have in your profile — can show lenders whether you can (responsibly) handle different kinds of credit.

Essentially, doing well in this factor means showing a diverse mix of credit, such as having a combination of revolving credit lines, like credit cards, and installment products, including student, auto, and mortgage loans. While you don’t need every type of credit product out there to do well, only sporting a single type of credit is hardly diverse.

All in all, if your current credit profile is very limited, perhaps consisting of just one or two credit cards, then closing one of those cards can have a significant impact on your credit mix factor. On the other hand, if you have a healthy combination of credit products, all in good standing, then closing a single card may not cause much (if any) damage to this particular factor.

Credit Mix Graphic

An ideal credit mix contains a combination of revolving credit lines, such as credit cards, as well as installment credit, like auto and home loans.

For instance, in Leonardo’s case, his credit profile has several revolving credit lines as well as a couple of installment loans — a fairly diverse mix. Were Leonardo to close a single credit card account, the impact to his credit mix factor would be fairly small. However, he may see some damage were he to close multiple credit card accounts.

You May Reduce the Credit Damage with a New, Better Card

Despite the potential negative consequences, there are plenty of good reasons to close a credit card account. The last card I canceled, for example, didn’t offer enough perks and benefits to cover its hefty annual fee, so Mr. Card met Ms. Shredder — and that was all she wrote.

On the plus side, you may be able to reduce the damage done when you cancel a credit card. How? Well, simply by replacing it with a newer, better card.

Alright, so a new card won’t help you with your average account age, particularly if you cancel one of your older cards. That being said, however, a new card can provide a boost to your available credit (and, thus, to your utilization rate), as well as help maintain diversity in the types of credit present in your credit profile.

Of course, the thing to remember when opening a new credit card is that each credit application results in a hard credit inquiry, and each hard inquiry may drop your credit score by a few points. At the same time, the damage from a single inquiry is generally minimal and it will likely have little to no impact after six months or so.

To avoid collecting a series of hard inquiries, be sure you pick the card for which you are most qualified. If you’re not sure about your chances of approval, you can check for pre-qualification offers before applying.

Pre-qualification relies on a soft credit inquiry, which won’t impact your credit score, to get a general idea of your credit risk and determine the card for which you are most likely to be approved. Although pre-qualification doesn’t guarantee approval, it can be a good way to estimate your chances without hurting your credit.

Good Credit | Fair Credit | Bad Credit

Best Cards for Good Credit

One of the more confusing aspects of consumer credit is that there are so many definitions for different types of credit. The exact credit score range for “good” credit, for instance, will vary based on the model used. For FICO, scores above 670 are considered “good” or better. In the VantageScore model, “good” scores are over 700.

In the consumer credit world, having good credit is the key to unlocking great credit card rewards and awesome interest deals. For instance, some of our favorite credit cards for good credit, listed below, include options for killer cash back rewards, awesome air miles programs, and intro 0% APR offers that’ll make your new card your go-to card.

Discover it® - Cashback Match™ Review

at Discover Card'ssecure website

GOOD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
5.0
OVERALL RATING
5.0/5.0
  • Earn 5% cash back at different places each quarter like gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants, Amazon.com, or wholesale clubs up to the quarterly maximum each time you activate.
  • INTRO OFFER: Discover will match ALL the cash back earned at the end of your first year, automatically.
  • Redeem your cash back for any amount, any time. Cash rewards never expire.
  • Use your rewards instantly at Amazon.com checkout.
  • No annual fee.
  • Click "APPLY NOW" to see rates, rewards, FICO® Credit Score terms, Cashback Match™ details & other information.
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
0% for 14 months
0% for 14 months
11.99% - 23.99% Variable
$0
Good/Excellent
GOOD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
5.0
OVERALL RATING
5.0/5.0
  • Unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase — it's automatic
  • Earn a $150 Bonus after you spend $500 on purchases in your first 3 months from account opening
  • 0% Intro APR for 15 months from account opening on purchases and balance transfers, then a variable APR of 15.99-24.74%. Balance transfer fee is 5% of the amount transferred, $5 minimum
  • No minimum to redeem for cash back
  • Cash Back rewards do not expire as long as your account is open
  • No annual fee
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
0% for 15 months
0% for 15 months
15.99% - 24.74% Variable
$0
Excellent/Good
GOOD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
5.0
OVERALL RATING
5.0/5.0
  • Earn a $150 Bonus after you spend $500 on purchases in your first 3 months from account opening
  • Earn 5% cash back on up to $1,500 in combined purchases in bonus categories each quarter you activate
  • Enjoy new 5% categories each quarter like gas stations, restaurants and drugstores
  • Unlimited 1% cash back on all other purchases - it's automatic
  • 0% Intro APR for 15 months from account opening on purchases and balance transfers, then a variable APR of 15.99-24.74%. Balance transfer fee is 5% of the amount transferred, $5 minimum
  • No minimum to redeem for cash back
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
0% for 15 months
0% for 15 months
15.99% - 24.74% Variable
$0
Excellent/Good

+See More Cards for Good Credit

Best Cards for Fair Credit

Consumers with “fair” credit tend to be those currently building their credit, perhaps as a student or someone rebuilding from past mistakes. Consumers in this category will have FICO scores from 580 to 669 and/or a VantageScore between 650 and 699.

Although the card options for those with “fair” credit aren’t quite as appealing as those for consumers with “good” credit, there are still good deals to be had, and the interest you pay will still likely be better than a subprime, bad-credit card. Our top-rated picks even include options for earning cash back rewards.

FAIR CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.9
OVERALL RATING
4.5/5.0
  • Earn unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, every day
  • Use your QuicksilverOne card and get 50% back as a statement credit on your monthly Spotify Premium subscription, now through April 2018
  • No rotating categories or sign-ups needed to earn cash rewards; plus, cash back won't expire for the life of the account and there's no limit to how much you can earn
  • Get access to a higher credit line after making your first 5 monthly payments on time
  • Fraud coverage if your card is ever lost or stolen
  • Use online banking to access your account, even from your smartphone, with our mobile app
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
24.99% (Variable)
$39
Average, Fair, Limited
FAIR CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.8
OVERALL RATING
3.8/5.0
  • Pay no annual fee
  • Get access to a higher credit line after making your first 5 monthly payments on time
  • Fraud coverage if your card is lost or stolen
  • Use online banking to access your account, even from your smartphone, with our mobile app
  • Pay by check, online or at a local branch, all with no fee - and pick the monthly due date that works best for you
  • Get access to your account 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
24.99% (Variable)
$0
Average, Fair, Limited
Credit One Bank® Platinum Visa® for Building Credit Review

at Credit One'ssecure website

FAIR CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.7
OVERALL RATING
4.0/5.0
  • See if you Pre-Qualify without harming your credit score.
  • This fully unsecured credit card with no deposit requirement can be helpful in growing or building credit. Your account activity will be reported monthly to all three major credit bureaus.
  • All the features you want in a credit card are included. Get 1% cash back on eligible purchases, take advantage of free online credit score tracking, and enjoy credit line increase opportunities. Terms apply.
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
16.99% - 24.99% Variable
$0 - $99
Fair

+See More Cards for Fair Credit

Best Cards for Bad Credit

At the bottom of the pack, those with “bad” credit have likely made a few financial blunders, such as missing payments, defaulting on an account, or even bankruptcy. FICO score considers “bad” scores to be anything under 579, and you’ll have a “poor” or “bad” VantageScore if you’re below 649.

With “bad” credit, you’ll probably be stuck choosing between a secured credit card (which will require a deposit) or an unsecured subprime card — which will likely come with a high interest rate and big fees. Be sure to select a card that reports to all three credit bureaus, as do our options below, so that your new card can help you build your credit score.

Fingerhut Credit Account Review

at Fingerhut'ssecure website

BAD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.7
OVERALL RATING
4.0/5.0
  • Holiday gifts they'll like, payments you'll love! Use your line of credit to shop over 550,000 items from great brands like Samsung, KitchenAid, and DeWalt
  • Take advantage of low monthly payments if you apply and are accepted for a Fingerhut Credit Account issued by WebBank, who determines eligibility and qualifications for the terms of credit
  • Fast, easy online application process and a quick decision
  • Not an access card
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
See Issuer Website
$0
Poor Credit
BAD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.6
OVERALL RATING
4.0/5.0
  • No annual fee, and all the credit building benefits with responsible card use
  • Unlike a prepaid card, it builds credit when used responsibly, with regular reporting to the 3 major credit bureaus
  • You will get an initial $200 credit line after making a security deposit of $49, $99, or $200, determined based on your creditworthiness
  • Get access to a higher credit line after making your first 5 monthly payments on time with no additional deposit needed
  • Easily manage your account 24/7 with online access, by phone or using our mobile app
  • It's a credit card accepted at millions of locations worldwide
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
24.99% (Variable)
$0
Limited, Bad
Total Visa® Card Review

at the issuer'ssecure website

BAD CREDIT RATING
★★★★★
4.5
OVERALL RATING
3.5/5.0
  • Checking Account Required
  • Fast and easy application process; response provided in seconds
  • A genuine VISA card accepted by merchants nationwide across the USA and online
  • Manageable monthly payments
  • If approved, simply pay a Processing Fee to open your account and access your available credit
  • Reports monthly to all three major credit bureaus
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
N/A
N/A
See Terms
See Terms
Fair, Bad Credit

+See More Cards for Bad Credit

Consider All the Impacts Before You Close a Card

Overall, the credit impacts from closing a credit account depend strongly on your individual credit profile and the specific account in question. The older the account, or the higher the credit limit, the larger the impact to your credit score from closing the account. You should carefully consider all the potential consequences before closing any credit accounts, even those you no longer use.

Refraining from closing old accounts can be particularly important if you intend to apply for major financing, such as a mortgage or auto loan, in the near future. Even if the impacts from closing the account are minimal, any sudden decrease in your score before a big loan application can be considered a warning sign by potential lenders and impact your rate offer or general approval chances.

Fortunately for me, I chose my first card well, selecting one without annual fees or other costs that would make it expensive to carry. Since it doesn’t cost me anything to keep it open — and it would definitely cost me credit points to close it — that card has a permanent place in my wallet (and a warm place in my memories).