The lucrative game of maxing out credit card rewards may soon come to an end with some consumers hitting the points-and-miles jackpot and others being left out.
The end appears to be near because card companies have tired of consumers who’ve binged on the best rewards without generating commensurate card company profits. Major retailers also have complaints about how big rewards programs work.
Why Cards Offer Rewards
Big banks originally offered attractive rewards to motivate consumers to apply for new cards, become steady customers, and boost profits.
Instead, many consumers gamed the system, signing up for cards, spending just enough to secure big signup bonuses and then abandoning the cards or paying their balances in full every month to avoid interest charges and late-payment fees. Consumers also learned to cancel premium cards before they had to pay the annual fees that card companies often waived for the first year.
“The gamble that generous rewards would make cardholders spend more profligately didn’t pan out,” says Quartz. “It just made this subset of card users diversify by signing up for a higher quantity of generous cards.”
The Wall Street Journal recently described a couple who flew around the world with free business-class airline tickets, thanks to big signup bonuses from their his-and-hers Chase Sapphire Reserve® cards and points they’d accumulated from other cards. Their trip took them from San Francisco to Taiwan, Japan, Serbia, and Germany, and then home again.
Introduced in the summer of 2016, the Chase Sapphire Reserve® card initially offered a 100,000-point signup bonus, worth $1,500 in travel, for customers who spent $4,000 in the first 90 days after they obtained the card.
Gaming card reward programs was once a niche pursuit. Over time, however, it has become a mainstream hobby. That has hurt card companies since they have to pay for the rewards their customers redeem.
“After ratcheting up the perks for several years, banks hit peak rewards frenzy about two years ago,” the WSJ reported. “Now banks face increasing costs associated with the cards.”
Card Companies are Cutting Back on Perks
Some card companies have already cut back some of their card perks. Chase and Citi no longer offer price protection benefits, which reimburses consumers when they find a lower price for a previous purchase. Discover and American Express have also limited some of their card benefits.
Now banks face increasing costs associated with the cards. — WSJ
Smaller intro bonuses and fewer card perks may cause consternation, concern, and disappointment for savvy consumers who aim to optimize their rewards and live large at the card companies’ expense.
For these card enthusiasts, high-value cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve®, American Express® Gold, and Marriott Rewards® Premier Credit Card “aren’t just cards that facilitate everyday spending . . . They’re an essential way to score things like free flights and cash back,” according to Vox.
By the way, the 100,000-point signup bonus for the Chase Sapphire Reserve® card was halved in early 2017 to 50,000 points, worth $750 in travel. That’s still more than enough to offset the card’s $550 annual fee.
Retailers aren’t happy with consumer card habits either. Some are so determined to quash cards that offer especially valuable rewards that they’re arguing their case in court.
Merchants currently aren’t allowed to choose which cards within a brand they want to accept. Instead, if they accept some cards with a brand (e.g., Visa, MasterCard), they must accept all cards within that brand, including the expensive ones.
Amazon, Target, and Home Depot are among the retailers that want to choose which individual cards within a brand they’ll accept, The Wall Street Journal reported. Given that choice, retailers likely would refuse the cards with the biggest rewards since those are the most costly for them. That would be unwelcome news for consumers who use those cards.
The Best Signup Bonuses Still Available
Despite the controversy, card companies aren’t likely to severely curtail or outright end their reward programs anytime soon. Rather, they’ll probably rejigger their cards to offer less attractive signup bonuses and fewer perks. Rewards will be designed to discourage gaming and encourage — or should we say “reward” — more profitable card use.
Happily, some cards still offer great benefits right now. Here are five to consider while you can still apply for them. You’ll need good or excellent credit to be approved.
4.7
Capital One announced the addition of transfer partners to its travel rewards program in late 2018, making the big signup bonus offered by this card even more valuable. Even better, the annual fee is waived for the first year, which means no fees to eat into your bonus.
4.7
With this card, you’ll receive a large signup bonus when you meet the minimum spend on new purchases in the first 90 days after you open your account. Those points are worth 1.25¢ each when you redeem them for travel through Chase Travel℠. Earn three points per $1 for spending up to $150,000 per year for travel and select business categories.
4.8
With the Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card, you can use your miles to fly with any airline or stay at any hotel with no blackout dates, or transfer your miles to more than a dozen travel loyalty programs. The signup bonus can result in serious travel mile rewards if you meet the time and purchase criteria.
4.9
Meet the minimum spend on new purchases in the first 90 days after you open your account to earn the Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card‘s signup bonus. For example, 50,000 points can be redeemed through Chase for $625 in travel. You can also transfer your points, one-for-one, to select airline and hotel loyalty programs. The annual fee for the Preferred card is much less than the premium Reserve card currently offering a similar signup bonus.
4.9
This card offers a no-annual-fee way to earn transferable Venture miles, but the Capital One VentureOne Rewards Credit Card bonus isn’t quite as large as that for its more expensive sibling. However, you can still redeem your miles to fly with any airline or stay at any hotel with no blackout dates.
Get Your Bonuses While You Still Can
While it’s hard to say when these generous signup offers and extensive card perks will start to diminish, it won’t be overnight, and there are still plenty of cards with from which to choose for the time being. The bottom line? Quartz says it best: “Get your 50,000-point bonuses while you still can.”
Advertiser Disclosure
CardRates.com is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation for referrals for many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear across CardRates.com (including, for example, the order in which they appear). CardRates.com does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers.
Editorial Note: Our site content is not provided or commissioned by any credit card issuer(s). Opinions expressed on CardRates.com are the author's alone, not those of any credit card issuer, and have not been reviewed, approved, or otherwise endorsed by credit card issuers. Every reasonable effort has been made to maintain accurate information; however, all credit card offer details, including information about rewards, signup bonuses, introductory offers, and other terms and conditions, is presented without warranty. Clicking on any offer on CardRates.com will direct you to the issuer's website, where you can review the current terms and conditions of the offer.
About the Author
