2018 Chase Freedom vs. Discover it® Credit Card

Chase Freedom vs. Discover it® Credit Card

credit card advice

Brittney Mayer
By: Brittney Mayer
Posted: January 12, 2018
Opinions expressed here are ours alone, and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by any issuer. Site may be compensated through the issuer affiliate programs.

In the modern consumer marketplace, many industries are often dominated by two leading brands and their latest products. If you want a soda, for instance, you’re likely choosing between some version of Pepsi or Coke. Similarly, most people likely carry a phone sporting the latest version of either Android or iOS.

When it comes to cash back credit card rewards, the two biggest names to beat are Chase Freedom® and Discover it®, similar cards that pack a lot of rewards punch for consumers who can make the most of them. But while both cards operate on the same cash back rewards structure — quarterly rotating bonus categories — a variety of small differences set them apart.

Signup Bonus | Rewards | Qualifying | Networks | Summary

Signup Bonus: Quick Reward vs. Long-Term Savings

One of the first things a prospective cardholder may notice when comparing the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® cards is the all-important signup bonus. The Chase Freedom® offers a more traditional signup bonus, namely a one-time, lump-sum cash bonus that becomes available when a new cardholder meets the minimum spending requirement on the card within the first 90 days after you open the account.

CASH BACK RATING

★★★★★
4.7

OVERALL RATING

5.0/5.0
  • Earn a $150 Bonus after you spend $500 on purchases in your first 3 months from account opening
  • Earn 5% cash back on up to $1,500 in combined purchases in bonus categories each quarter you activate
  • Enjoy new 5% categories each quarter
  • Unlimited 1% cash back on all other purchases - it's automatic
  • 0% Intro APR for 15 months from account opening on purchases and balance transfers, then a variable APR of 16.24-24.99%. Balance transfer fee is 5% of the amount transferred, $5 minimum
  • No minimum to redeem for cash back
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
0% Intro APR on Purchases for 15 months
0% Intro APR on Balance Transfers for 15 months
16.24% - 24.99% Variable
$0
Excellent/Good

Given the fairly small spending requirement of the Freedom’s signup bonus, it should be easy for just about any cardholder to meet within the 90-day period. Since most signup bonuses are deposited within six weeks of earning them, this can mean a nice lump sum in just a few months.

In contrast, the Discover it® card has a relatively unique signup bonus offer that Discover refers to as Cashback Match®. Rather than offering a quick flat-rate sum, Discover’s Cashback Match® program gives cardholders a one-time bonus at the end of the first year, equal to the total amount of cash back rewards earned with their Discover it® card during that first year.

Discover it® - Cashback Match™ Review

at Discover Card'ssecure website

CASH BACK RATING

★★★★★
5.0

OVERALL RATING

5.0/5.0
  • Earn 5% cash back at different places each quarter like gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants, Amazon.com, or wholesale clubs up to the quarterly maximum each time you activate.
  • Earn 1% cash back on all other purchases.
  • INTRO OFFER: Discover will match ALL the cash back earned at the end of your first year, automatically.
  • Redeem your cash back for any amount, any time. Cash rewards never expire.
  • Use your rewards instantly at Amazon.com checkout.
  • No annual fee.
Intro (Purchases)
Intro (Transfers)
Regular APR
Annual Fee
Credit Needed
0% for 14 months
0% for 14 months
12.24% - 24.24% Variable
$0
Good/Excellent

So, for example, if you were to make $3,000 worth of qualifying 5% cash back purchases with your Discover it® card during the first year, you’d earn a total of $150 cash back on those purchases. Under the Cashback Match® program, you would then receive an additional one-time $150 cash back bonus on your one-year account anniversary.

And if you spend enough to max out your 5% cash back category every three months ($1,500 in qualifying bonus category purchases per activated quarter), your total cash back would be $300, which means your Cashback Match® would be a huge $300 at the end of the year. And that’s without adding any additional cash back earned at the unlimited 1% cash back rate for all other card purchases.

Rewards: Duel of the Rotating Categories

When you get right down to it, the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® cards have a ton of similarities, starting with the fact that neither card charges an annual fee. Both cards also offer a nice introductory 0% APR offer good on both new purchases and balance transfers — and both charge a balance transfer fee, though Discover has the slight edge with a 3% fee instead of the Freedom’s 5% balance transfer fee.

Of course, the real déjà vu comes when you look at the rewards systems operated by the two cards. Both the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® cardholders earn cash back rewards, with bonus 5% cash back rewards earned for purchases in specific bonus categories that change each quarter. Each card in the pair has the same quarterly purchase cap, as well, limiting bonus cash back to the first $1,500 in combined category purchases each quarter.

Chase Freedom 2018 Cash Back Calendar

Check the Chase Freedom® 2018 Cash Back Calendar to see the bonus categories for each quarter.

Since 5% cash back is only as good as its categories, both cards offer popular everyday bonus categories, including things like gas, groceries, and restaurant purchases. Most quarters will also offer a secondary category in a more niche area, such as wholesale clubs or Amazon purchases. Both cards will require you to “activate” your bonus category each quarter to be eligible for the 5% cash back rewards.

Additionally, Discover cardholders also get access to a vast collection of Discover Deals, a huge collection of special deals from dozens of popular retailers. Members can access exclusive discounts and coupons, as well as earn bonus cash back on eligible purchases. For example, the Discover Deals portal can help you earn an extra 5% cash back on Walmart.com or Old Navy online purchases.

Discover it® 2018 Cash Back Calendar

The Discover it® 2018 Cash Back Calendar shows the bonus categories for each quarter.

For many credit card rewards aficionados, the best way to maximize their cash back rewards is by using both cards. Essentially, while the bonus categories do occasionally overlap between the Chase Freedom® and Discover it®, it’s infrequent enough that you could effectively double your 5% cash back potential by obtaining both cards.

As an example, the last quarter of 2017, the Discover it® card offered bonus cash back on Amazon.com and Target purchases, while the Chase Freedom® provided 5% cash back for Walmart and department store purchases. Since it’s likely at least some portion of your seasonal shopping takes place with one or more of these retailers, using both cards could create a nice stockpile of cash back to use when the holiday bills come ’round.

And the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® make it easy to redeem your cash back, which you can get as a statement credit or a deposit into a qualifying bank account. If you already have a card that earns Chase Ultimate Rewards, like the Chase Sapphire Preferred® card or the elite Chase Sapphire Reserve℠, then you can also exchange your Chase Freedom® cash back rewards for Ultimate Rewards points through the Ultimate Rewards portal.

Qualifying: Credit Scores & Chase 5/24 Rule

Other than a few fees and specific bonus categories, the biggest differences between the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® cards stem from the different issuers and networks (the latter of which is discussed in the next section). How the issuers come into play is more than just a matter of which bank you make your payments to; it also tends to play a big role in the card’s approval requirements.

For instance, Chase is generally considered to have some of the higher credit qualifications for their cards, and the Chase Freedom® is little exception. You’ll want to have a FICO credit score over 700 for decent approval chances, though a higher score will net you a better APR and higher credit limit. The lowest FICO score reported by a reviewer accepted for the Chase Freedom® was 645, which is firmly in the “Fair” credit range.

Discover cards, on the other hand, are typically considered to be easier to obtain, with multiple reviewers reporting being approved for a Discover it® card with scores in the mid-500s. That being said, the average cardholder had a score over 650, and you’ll still need a credit score in the 700 or better range to qualify for the lowest APRs and highest credit limits.

Another important way the cards’ issuers come into the picture is through application limitations in place from each issuer. Chase, for example, operates under what’s known as the “5/24 Rule,” which means that most applicants will be automatically rejected for a new Chase credit card if they have opened more than five new credit accounts in the last 24 months.

While Discover doesn’t have any specific rules that prevent you from applying for a single Discover it® card, the issuer does have a rule in place that restricts the number of Discover it® cards you can have at any one time to two. It also requires that you wait at least 12 months after opening your first Discover it® credit card account before you can open a second card account.

Networks: Discover vs. Visa

The final area in which cardholders might notice differences between the Discover it® and Chase Freedom® cards will be related to the processing networks, as the Discover it® card will obviously run on the Discover network, while the Chase Freedom® operates on the Visa network. This affects your card use in a few ways that will primarily be noticeable through your card’s acceptance rate and peripheral benefits.

Not too long ago, Visa was the solid leader in worldwide acceptance — but not anymore. Discover has made huge leaps in its number of overseas merchants and is now the most widely accepted network by volume, with 42 million worldwide merchants. In contrast, Visa and Mastercard are accepted by 40 million merchants globally, and American Express only 25 million merchants.

ValuePenguin Chart Showing Credit Card Network Merchant Acceptance

This chart from ValuePenguin shows the number of merchants accepting the four major credit card networks.

At the same time, Discover is accepted in only 175 countries, compared to Visa’s 200+, with limited to no Discover acceptance in some parts of Africa, South America, and the Middle East. Domestically, you likely won’t notice much of a difference in acceptance rates, with both Visa and Discover accepted by 9 million US merchants across the country.

Beyond basic acceptance rates, the credit card network will also determine the extraneous perks and benefits cardholders enjoy. All Discover cardholders are given access to their FICO credit score for free each month, as well as price and purchase protection. Plus, you’ll receive $0 fraud liability and built-in auto rental insurance.

Visa cardholders enjoy access to many of the same perks, including an auto rental collision damage waiver, zero liability for fraudulent purchases, and emergency cash disbursement. Your Visa card will also allow you to use Visa’s Roadside Dispatch® service, a pay-per-use roadside assistance program.

Summary: Similar Cards with Complementary Rewards

To some dedicated consumers, there are only two types of people in the world: Android People and Apple People. Similarly, the Coke and Pepsi superfans out there know which they prefer — and they’re happy to share every reason why. For the savvy savers who love to make the most of credit card rewards, it all comes down to Chase Freedom® versus Discover it®.

But just like soda junkies who like to escalate their culinary creativity by blending both brands in the same cup, credit card rewards rebels know that the Chase Freedom® and Discover it® cards are more alike than different, and it’s those similarities that make the two cards a great duo for maximizing your cash back rewards.